Writers' News

For a wide range of services for writers, visit our links page

Writing Magazine

Competition Showcase | Online competition | WN competitions | WM competitions | Rules

Competition Showcase – The Art and Craft of Deception by Susan Butler

 

About Susan Butler
Susan Butler was born in Canada, and returned there as a teenager. ‘Like many readers I have been writing poetry and short stories since I was a little girl,’ she says. ‘But making a living as a social worker took precedence over any literary aspirations.’ However since retiring I decided to take courses in writing at a local university, joined a local writer's group, and also enrolled on the Writer's News short story correspondence course. This last step has proved most helpful, and has enabled me to have a short story accepted by The Lady My goal is to have more work accepted by short story publications.’

The Art and Craft of Deception

by Susan Butler



Although the card on the dashboard read Gemma Walker, Real Estate Agent for Palmer and Stewart, I’d yet to sell a single piece of real estate. Driving past number 10 The Drive, I’d usually slow down, or pull over to the kerb. Despite its condition the house fascinated me. It still retained its dignity, although, according to realtors, it had lain neglected for fifty years.
The residence faced the well-kept mansions opposite in unapologetic shabbiness. Sandwiched between two smart homes of the same period, the house with its mouldy stucco walls and peeling paintwork looked like a poor relation.
All the houses on the street were built between 1900 and 1905, at the height of the Arts and Crafts movement. With a direct line to London via the Thames Link, house prices had rocketed in Radwell. The six real estate offices in the village had all grown affluent from the area. But since I’d arrived from the London office the market had taken a sudden dive.
I’d heard number10 was the stuff dreams were made of. The wallpaper, curtains and furniture, said to date from the same period as the house, were as valuable as the property. Stories were rife about agents who’d tried to convince the owner to sell. But despite their various ploys they’d all been met by stubborn refusal. Dreams of fat commissions and fast sports cars had evaporated like summer dew. Mrs Thornberry would not sell.
I was desperate to see inside the house. The deadline for my design course assignment, based on the Arts and Crafts movement was looming closer. I’d yet to start working on it, but I felt sure I’d get a good mark if I could only get access to the house. And as to photographing the interior, that would be icing on the cake.
Parking across the street from number 10 as usual one morning I yawned and reached for my coffee thermos. The combination of working days and studying nights was taking its toll. Looking idly at the house I’d noticed that the only part of the property that seemed well maintained was the garden. I’d seen a gardener once pushing a wheelbarrow up the slope towards the back of the house.
As I watched the house this morning an elderly lady appeared from the side door. I assumed this was Mrs Thornberry, I’d heard she lived alone. Dressed in a knobbly cream twin set and faded tweed skirt, and leaning heavily on a walking stick, she shuffled towards the pavement in her slippers. She pulled the black wheelie-bin to the kerb, before walking back in the direction she’d come. A skinny white tomcat rubbed itself against the back of her legs.
It was then that I saw an opportunity to get access to number 10. When darkness fell I returned to the house, parking directly in front of the driveway. Around ten the back door squeaked open, and the cat was pushed outside. I slid a saucer of milk towards him. As he lowered its head to drink, I snatched the saucer and hoisting the cat under my arm, bolted for my car.
The next morning was a Sunday, and the church bells were ringing when I returned to number 10 with a wicker cat-box in one hand. Climbing the steep steps to the front door I knocked loudly. I felt sure Mrs Thornberry was home, she wasn’t a churchgoer, and the only times I’d seen her leave the house, were to go shopping.
After some time I heard shuffling footsteps in the hall, followed by the sound of a latch being pulled back and a chain released. The door opened an inch; Mrs Thornberry looked me up and down suspiciously.
‘Yes?’
‘Excuse me but I found this cat wandering in the village, I’ve noticed a white cat outside your house. Is it missing by any chance?’
‘Since you mention it I haven’t seen Sebastian this morning. He usually scratches at the kitchen door at seven sharp.’
Mrs Thornberry peered into the wicker basket where the cat cowered in the back.
‘I can’t see well in this light, you’d better come in’
She opened the door grudgingly, while I crossed the doorstep into another world. The hall walls were patterned with William Morris wallpaper in a sage willow design. Molten light streamed through a stained glass window half way up the stairs. Peasant women in white bonnets were bringing in the harvest, staking golden sheaves amidst fields of stubble.
I was so overcome I nearly forgot my mission. Then remembering, I hastily opened the basket; the cat leaped out and dashed upstairs.
‘That does look like Sebastian, but he’s a very timid cat. I can’t think how he ended up in the village.’ Mrs Thornberry looked at me sharply.
‘You look familiar, do I know you from somewhere?’
My heart sank.
‘You’d better wait in here while I check his collar.’
She showed me into a large room, dwarfed by an impressive stone Inglenook fireplace. A motto was carved into the mantle. ‘Have nothing in your houses that you do not know to be useful or believe to be beautiful.’
Two tall stained glass windows on either side featured barefooted- redheaded women. The one on the left was encircled with apple blossoms, while the one on the right was garlanded with pink roses. Their robes glowed indigo blue and saffron yellow against an olive green background.
As I stood in the middle of the room running my hand along the back of an embroidered chair, Mrs Thornberry appeared in the doorway with the cat in her arms.
‘Yes this is Sebastian, but I hope you’re not expecting a reward? I’m a pensioner living on a small stipend.’
‘That’s quite all right It’s very kind of you to ask me into your home. I’m studying the Arts and Crafts Movement at university, it’s a privilege to see William Morris designs outside a museum.’
Mrs Thornberry releasing the cat, who took one look at me and beat a hasty retreat. His owner sank wearily into the sofa; and turned to me with renewed interest.
‘My parents were very influenced by William Morris as you can see. The architect who built the house consulted him about the décor.’
She pointed to the dark oak bookshelves under the stained glass windows. ‘They collected books on the Arts and Crafts Movement as you can see. But I prefer a simpler style myself.’
The back garden could be seen clearly through the open conservatory. Pots of cream Arum lilies stood on either side of the patio doors, while white jasmine and pink clematis clambered over the glass roof. The herbaceous border, that stretched the whole length of the garden, glowed with crimson poppies, and indigo blue cornflowers. Mrs Thornberry’s voice grew wistful as I complimented her on her garden.
’My late husband landscaped everything when we first moved here. He loved that garden more than life itself.’
She turned her face away sadly, before patting the sofa cushion, and motioning me to join her.
‘ At least you’re not a real estate agent. I’ve been offered substantial amounts for this house, you know?’
I was beginning to feel guilty about deceiving Mrs Thornberry. She plumped up the scatter cushions. ‘I’ve never told anyone this before, but I can’t sell the house. You see, it would mean leaving my husband behind, and I couldn’t do that’
‘But it must be comforting taking these flowers to his grave.’
I motioned towards the herbaceous border.
‘Oh dear me no, my husband’s not buried in the cemetery, he’s much closer.’
Mrs Thornberry pointed in the direction of the flowerbeds.
My heart sank. Surely there were regulations about burying relatives in one’s garden? If not what were the ethical issues implicated by this situation?
Did one tell prospective buyers, and if so, when? Was it actually possible sell a house with a dead husband buried in the back garden?
Visions of walking into the real estate office triumphantly dangling the keys for number 10 vanished like a burst soap bubble.
‘I scattered his ashes over the herbaceous borders,’ Mrs Thornberry said as she showed me to the door. She placed her hand on my arm, and my relief was replaced with sympathy.
‘It’s nice to talk to someone who appreciates art, you must call again, I was thinking of cataloguing the collection, perhaps you could help?’ She looked down at her cat that who was winding himself around her legs and looking up expectantly.
‘And thank you for returning Sebastian, he looks as though he’s ready for his breakfast. I only give him cheap cat food, but he seems to like it.’
I hadn’t the heart to tell her he loved roast chicken. Thrusting the cat basket into her hands, I said.
‘You’re welcome to keep this if you like?’
As the door closed I turned with a sigh to confront my ramshackle car with its bumps, scratches and coat hanger aerial. Maybe the idea of documenting antique furniture wasn’t such a bad idea after all. It would beat the cut-throat real estate business. For the first time since arriving in Radwell I left number 10 with a spring in my step.


Judging comment
The best stories are usually character-driven, and a story about a change of character therefore stands a strong chance in any competition. And here we have the character study: Gemma Walker versus Mrs Thornberry. Gemma is very much a 21st century girl in a modern job and with modern ambitions. Mrs Thornberry, on the other hand, is a product of the early 20th century. The connection between the two is the house: a house that reflects the lifestyle of Mrs Thornberry, but which appeals to Gemma’s interest in art.
Susan Butler invents a clever ploy to enable Gemma to enter the house and therefore to establish contact with Mrs Thornberry: Gemma kidnaps the cat, and then makes a little fuss about returning it.
But from this small deceit we see a different Gemma emerging from the spell of the old lady and her house. It makes a fascinating, and quite moving, read.