Writers' News

For a wide range of services for writers, visit our links page

Writing Magazine

Competition Showcase | Online competition | WN competitions | WM competitions | Rules

Competition Showcase – MIRROR, MIRROR ON THE WALL by Moira Cooke

 

About Moira Cooke
Moira Cooke is married with two children and four grandchildren, all girls, and moved to Suffolk two years ago. ‘I worked as a teacher and private tutor for many years,’ she says, ‘including eight years living and working in Zambia and Zimbabwe. I began writing seriously in 1997 and have had women's fiction published in most of the leading women's magazines as well as children's stories published in several other magazines.
‘I have spent the last couple of years working on a book about experiences with my husband doing charity work in Zambia. It is entitled 'Bwanakula Thandi - the story of the Building of Kaputula School' and was self-published by Indepenpress (£7.99 from PenPress or on Amazon or contact moiracooke@belmoor.plus.com). Bwanakula Thandi means the grandmother of Thandi, an honorary name given to me by the Kaputula community.’

MIRROR, MIRROR ON THE WALL
By Moira Cooke

Sometimes I feel little more than an object of pity to my next door neighbours.
‘Poor Sandra, she lost the use of both legs in a car accident,’ I can hear one saying,
before the other one adds: ‘Then would you know, an early stroke cost her the powers of speech.’
To them Sandra is become a person of little account.
They are generous though, Ted and Barbara. They have a key to my house and drop round often enough. They let themselves in, plump up a few cushions, make me a cup of tea then enquire solicitously: ‘How are we today, Sandra?’
‘We are fine,’ I’m tempted to respond queen-like. As if my misfortunes have inexplicably created two of me. And in a way they have. First there’s me, then there’s my mirror, my window on the world. Though it’s funny to think installing the mirror was Ted’s idea in the first place.
‘It’ll give you a whole new dimension on life,’ he claimed as he fixed up a huge plate glass sheet along one empty wall in my downstairs bedroom.
It won’t give me back the use of my legs or the powers of speech, I reflect, even if it does allow me to watch the world and its antics beyond the boundary of their garden.
Yet this is precisely where Ted and Barbara grew careless. They were careless of exactly what I could see and as a result careless of what I might come to know. I know what time they get up, what time they go to bed, what time they eat, use the bathroom. The list is endless. Through the world in my mirror I’ve come to know things about Ted and Barbara they don’t even know about themselves . . .
Doreen, my helper, comes in daily. She gets me up, dresses me and seats me at an angle to my mirror. Then my day begins. Living my life through a plate glass mirror tilted at an angle to reflect the outside world.
‘Tennyson, wasn’t it, wrote a poem about someone like you,’ muses Doreen. ‘The Lady of Shalott, as I recall. She was locked in a tower and forced to live her life through a mirror angled to reflect the world below. ‘Winding down to Camelot . . .’ she quotes.
Or Summertown, as it is in my case. For a cleaning lady I’m impressed. Maybe the same poem is where Ted got his idea from, though secretly I doubt he’s the sort that reads poetry.
Summertown lies a mere stone’s throw away. Yet if it wasn’t for my mirror, it might as well be a million miles away. But if I were to throw a stone its trajectory would travel in a straight line across Ted and Barbara’s garden.
And this is precisely where they became careless. They realise I’ve become addicted to what goes on in Summertown, but what they forgot is that I’m equally addicted to the goings-on in their world. Until my mirror revealed all, I really had no idea at all what my neighbours got up to.
Take Barbara for example, she adores sunbathing in the altogether in their back garden. Two little sun-baked melons and a pinball of fluff pointing heavenwards as soon as the sun makes its appearance. In the privacy (sic!) of her back garden, there is of course no problem with that.
Ted frequently takes photos of her, darting about like a crazed honey bee between the verbena and the lavatera bushes and vying for the best angle. And that also is his right. He’s even turned their back shed into some sort of photographic workshop. I nearly said dark room but I guess that shows how disconnected from the world I’ve become. These things are all digital nowadays anyways.
‘Bit of a hobby,’ he confessed to me on one of his visits handing across photos from their latest holiday. Not of course photos of Barbara naked as the day she was born. ‘Just look at that for clarity,’ he boasted.
I wanted tell him the mirror also could be very precise. Its images are never blurred. Like Ted’s digitally enhanced images, I suppose.
‘I wonder what he does with all those photos of Barbara?’ I mused after he’d gone.
The mirror of course, my constant companion, declined to respond. It simply conjured up the next image for my perusal. I may have lost the use of my legs and my speech but there’s nothing wrong with my brain. And that’s where Ted and Barbara got it all so wrong.
It’s as if the mirror senses what I’m waiting for. Doreen gives it an extra spit and a shine and in response it dutifully coughs up the next image. Ted has added a small extension to his printing workshop turning it into a kind of office.
A man carrying a black briefcase has started calling once or twice a week. He appears very businesslike, but what does he come there for? To collect Ted’s digitally enhanced photos of Barbara?
Of late the man with the briefcase has started coming around when Ted’s not there. Only he doesn’t bring his briefcase with him on these occasions. He stays for longer too. That makes me somewhat uneasy, but I’m no squealer.
Some weeks later Ted calls round alone. ‘I expect you’re wondering where Barbara is?’ he asks nonchalantly. As usual he’s not anticipating any response on my part. He’ll answer himself anyway in due course.
I’m careful not to glance in the direction of my mirror in case it gives Ted ideas. One glance and Ted also might realise I witnessed the terrible row which raged last night for over an hour between him and Barbara. Backwards and forwards it went, him pointing his finger and accusing her. Of what? Betrayal? Unfaithfulness?
Then Barbara in turn shrieking and pointing her finger at him. Had she no idea he was trading co-operation in his new found hobby for her reputation? Had she no inkling of what her husband was up to? Even the mirror and I had worked that one out.
‘Barbara has gone on holiday to her mother’s,’ Ted reveals. ‘It could be for an extended visit.’
A longer vacation than either of you intended, I’m thinking.
Ted pauses, eyes glued to the mirror. Slowly he rotates his head through ninety degrees as if following the trajectory of an imaginary stone over the fence, across their pristine lawn where Barbara sunbathes in the all-together, then straight in through the open dining room window where last night’s vicious row took place.
‘Still enjoying the view from your window, Sandra?’ Ted asks. ‘It must make such a difference. Why you can see . . . almost everything.’
Almost everything, I want to echo.
Without warning Ted snatches up a metal hairbrush from the dressing table and hurls it against the mirror shattering it into a thousand pieces. My life is over more surely than when Ted turns abruptly, snatches up a kitchen knife from my lunch tray and plunges it into my side.
‘Bitch, you saw everything,’ he spits out like a cobra spitting venom. ‘Well, dead people tell no lies.’
Snatching my mobile phone from where it lies at my side, he sneaks away like a thief in the night secure in the belief that no one will find the body until morning. My breath comes in heaving gasps. I mustn’t yield to a pain greater even than that of losing the use of both legs and speech.
Around me lie shards of glass of varying sizes. One large one has landed in my lap. I pick it up and gaze at the remnants of me. I’m dying. Ted knew that, yet didn’t wait round for the final curtain call. I feel inside the woven purse that hangs constantly around my neck.
I’m not finished yet. Broken maybe, but not finished. Nor is my mirror. The mirror must reveal one final truth. Careless, that’s what Ted and Barbara were, giving me a window not just to the outside world but also to their private sick world. I watched Ted throttle Barbara last night with his bare hands. That’s how I know for certain, she’s paying a long visit to her mother.
I’m going away too but not for a visit. There’s no coming back from where I’m going. Yet the mirror has one final role to play. I extract a lipstick from my purse.
‘Fancy wearing lippie in her condition,’ I once overheard Barbara’s snide remark to Ted. As if my hearing had vanished along with my legs and speech.
Using the lipstick I write in shaky letters on the shard of glass: TED DID IT. HE KILLED BARBARA AND HE KILLED ME.
I struggle to prop up the glass where Doreen will find it when she comes to bed me down for the night. Our new arrangement, evenings as well as mornings, something else Ted forgot. He didn’t even wait to finish me off properly but left me with just enough of myself to use the mirror one last time, the mirror he so kindly installed for me.
He imagines he’ll be long gone by morning. Yet if the mirror plays its role, the police will have him before he can say ‘Mirror, mirror on the wall . . .’ And it certainly won’t be him who proves the fairest of them all.


Judging comment
Foreshadowing. That’s a technique that short story writers often use, and it’s one that adds to our enjoyment of and involvement in a story. It is also something that Moira Cooke uses very effectively in her Mirror, Mirror on the Wall – a story that won second place in the Writing Magazine Crime Story competition.
Early in the story Sandra, the principle character here, observes that it is ‘funny to think that installing the mirror was Ted’s idea in the first place.’ That raises a major question: why should it be funny that it was Ted’s idea? What is it about the mirror that makes Ted’s involvement at all ‘funny’?
The mirror, we soon learn, provides the handicapped Sandra with a view of the outside world. More precisely, it provides a view of Ted and Barbara’s house and garden next door. Sandra sees and reports a good many unusual and interesting things happening in her neighbours’ place, and in the process she leads up to the crime of the crime story: Ted murders Barbara.
But Ted soon realises what Sandra must have seen and has little choice but to murder her as well; one crime leads to another. The climax sees a dying Sandra leaving the evidence that will lead the police to arrest Ted.
So it is ironic that Ted himself should have installed the mirror – the mirror that proved to be the agent of his destruction. Hence the foreshadowing ‘funny to think’. ‘Funny’ is not perhaps an exact word to use, but it is one commonly used in everyday speech.
It is a good place to end. Moira Cooke could have gone on to relate what happened after the bodies were discovered, how the police reacted to Sandra’s message, how Ted was arrested, and what happened at his trial. In fact, the story could have gone on and on. But knowing when to stop is an important skill. And Moira stops her story at just the right point: the crimes have been committed, the evidence left. We can decide for ourselves what happens from there.